One-on-one versus Classroom Instruction

The age old debate about God and Country is whether or not to require one-on-one instruction with the pastor/counselor, or to teach it in a classroom setting to a large group of children. There is no “right” or “wrong” way to do it. Here are some thoughts on this issue.

 

There is no better motivation for a young person than having the pastor personally involved in teaching God and Country on an individual basis. God and Country will have the biggest impact in this one-on-one setting. Click here to read the testimony of Rev. Dr. William H. Willimon, a United Methodist Bishop. And at the younger levels, one-on-one instruction can also make for great family ministry. Children will complete the bulk of the curriculum at home with the help of the parents, and then bring their work to the pastor for review. Parents welcome the opportunity to share their faith with their children and are often surprised by their children’s eagerness to learn more about God. In larger congregations, this one-on-one approach may not be feasible. It is very time consuming and can limit the number of youth a pastor can teach. Scheduling can be an issue.

 

Offering structured classes requires more organization and adult volunteers. It requires lesson plans, craft supplies, and a 4 to 6 week time commitment for the younger levels and an 8 to 12 week time commitment for the older programs. But it also has the potential of attracting more youth and becoming an outreach ministry to Scouts in the community. Click here to read testimonial from Buena Vista UMC. Structured classes do not necessarily eliminate parental involvement in the program. Pastors can choose to require parents to attend, and even require parents to complete the Adult Mentor curriculum. Some families need this type of structure in order to complete the program. A larger group setting also allows for greater synergy and peer learning and sharing.

Choosing to take the children through the program individually or offering structured classes depends on your individual situation. A pastor or congregation does not have to be pigeonholed into doing the God and Country program one particular way. God and Country is flexible and offers a myriad of choices to fit your circumstances and needs.

Print PDF Version